Friday, February 22, 2019

Quantum Duplicity: running with the hares, hunting with the hounds


Quantum Duplicity: running with the hares, hunting with the hounds
Einstein famously decried quantum mechanics by claiming that God does not play dice – and an exasperated Bohr is said to have replied to Einstein: “Stop telling God what to do.”
The conventional way to visualize quantum mechanics has been a Schrodinger’s Cat: a mixture of a dead and a live cat.
Instead, let us look at the phrase ‘hunting with the hounds while running with the hares’.


a  a).     To support or attempt to placate both sides of a conflict or dispute. 
“Many have criticized the government of runningwith the hare and hunting with the hounds regarding the territorial dispute between the two nations.”.
2  b)  To act duplicitously or hypocritically; to speak or act out against something while engaging or 
taking part in it. 
“Howcan you be taken seriously as a reformer when you have continued to accept gifts? You 
can't run with the hare and hunt with the hounds, Senator”.
3  c)  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8cbbjaWlo4M : ‘You can’t run with the hares and hunt with the hounds’: means: ‘you can’t have it both ways’.

Some people phrase it differently, as a moral imperative: ‘You shouldn’t run with the hares and hunt with the hounds’. That is: you can, but you shouldn’t.
Other dictionary explanations of this phrase (similar to a) & b) above) :
a) keeping an equal distance from two parties in a conflict
b) duplicitous behavior of talking up relations with one party, while secretly supporting the other.
The perfect real-life – or realpolitik – example of this phrase is the almost seamless relationship between Pakistan's ISI/Army and the bevy of terrorist groups that they harbor.
The question is: can this phrase be taken as an example of ‘quantum duplicity’? This directly contradicts the simple-minded explanation #3: sometimes you can have it both ways.
A similar phrase is: ‘You can’t have your cake and eat it too’.  Well, if it’s a quantum cake, maybe you can. Although David Bohm didn’t agree (he was closer to Einstein’s camp):
See also, the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics (i.e. you can have your cake or not in parallel universes, to simplify a bit):
and the more conventional (‘You can’t have your cake and eat it – unless you happen to be a quantum physicist…’):
Explanation (a), maintaining equidistance between two opposing parties in a conflict, is uninteresting. The second explanation, (b), is more promising, but there is a problem: it seems to be asymmetric: the party indulging in this behavior is actually supporting one party while merely pretending to support the other.
In quantum mechanics this behavior may be (but does not have to be) symmetric: the duplicitous party really supports both groups simultaneously. Pakistan provides men and money to jehadis, but has also -  at times  - attacked them, with the Pakistan Army indeed suffering many casualties and deaths. Pakistanis quote this fact to support their contention that they are ‘taking action against terrorist groups’. Maybe Pakistan is actually a real Quantum State (because it does seem to do both!)? Perhaps it helps that there are many groups of jehadis (hounds?). Also, not everyone agrees about an answer to the question: who are the hares, and who are the hounds?
Implicit in duplicity is the idea of ‘plausible deniability’: You can get away with anything as long as you don’t get caught red-handed.
A parallel can be made to the quantum world: as long as no measurement is made, the quantum state exists in a superposition of both states (support group A/support Group B or live cat/dead cat). But as soon as a measurement is made the mask of quantum duplicity is torn off: the Quantum State collapses into one of two mutual orthogonal states. Similarly, you can look at a quantum cake (no measurement), but when it reaches your tongue, either it’s there or it isn’t (measurement).
Einstein would not be happy with this analogy either. Nor are the victims of real-politik. But that’s life.
Another word which captures the shape-shifting nature of reality is the word ‘frenemy’. Clearly, the word frenemy needs only one person in addition to yourself, while ‘hunting with hounds and running with the hares’ needs at least three.
However, one should clarify that one needs to invoke a quantum nature only when one entity is being discussed. If there are many entities then the more appropriate classical analog is the word ‘mixed strategy’ from game theory. A Hawk always follows a strategy of aggression, while a Dove always acts according to non-violent means. A mixed strategy is (say) 50% Hawk and 50% Dove, and can happen in two ways: a) 50% of the population is Hawk and 50% is always Dove, or b) each member of the population is Hawk 50% of the time and Dove 50% of the time. Alternative a) works well if the population contains an even number of individuals, where n ³ 2 (only in the 50%/50% case). But if n Is odd, then the only way to go is alternative b). If n is 1, the only possibility is quantum.
So it would be more accurate to describe Pakistan's game plan as mixed strategy, rather than quanum duplicity.

Monday, December 3, 2018

Actual Face-Mask Efficiency


Mask efficiency, really

There are two types of face masks available N95 and N99, the latter boasting 99% efficiency for PM, and being more expensive than the lower efficiency 95% masks. They filter airborne particles larger than 0.3 microns diameter. These are supposed to be in three sizes: small, medium and large. The problem is that faces come in all kinds of shapes and even the N99 masks cannot assure a perfect fit. This is important because, if they do not fit, a fraction of unfiltered air is being inhaled. This means that the effective efficiency is not really as high as the advertised 95% or 99%.

Let us call the advertised efficiency h, the leakage percentage l and the degraded efficiency e. The fraction of pollution that gets through is:

P = l + (1 - l)(1 - h)

The 1st terms is the unfiltered air, and the remainder (1 - l) does get filtered.

The effective efficiency is:

e = 1 – p = h (1 - l)

This can be tabulated as a function of varying leakage fraction l for both types of masks:


N95
N99
0
0.95
0.99
0.05
0.9025
0.9405
.1
0.855
0.891
.2
0.76
0.792
.3
0.665
0.693
.4
0.57
0.594
.5
0.475
0.495
.6
0.38
0.396
.7
0.285
0.297
.8
0.19
0.198
.9
0.095
0.099
1.0
0
0

The limiting cases of zero leakage and 100% leakage are as expected. 

A well-fitting N95 mask may be better than an ill-fitting N99 mask. As the leakage rate increases, there is not much to choose between ill-fitting N95 and N99 masks, as can be seen from the graph"

In fact, in the Army, you are required to shave off your beard because the face mask cannot protect you against poisonous gases or viruses since contaminated air will through the spaces between facial hairs. Face masks which really protect you do exist, but they are used for military or medical applications.

The question is: what is the leakage rate, actually? This is difficult to determine experimentally, but two papers [1,2] have tried to determine the number.

Lai et al [1] used poly-disperse ultrafine particles to challenge face masks worn by manikins:
“Performances of four different types of face-mask fits, varying from ideal to normal wearing practice, were also investigated. Under the pseudo-steady concentration environment, face-mask protection was found to be 45%, while under expiratory emissions, protection varied from 33 to 100% .”

Cherrie et al [2] report similar results:

“The masks’ filtration efficiency was tested by drawing airborne diesel exhaust through a section of the material and measuring the PM2.5 and black carbon (BC) concentrations upstream and downstream of the filtering medium. Four masks were selected for testing on volunteers. Volunteers were exposed to diesel exhaust inside an experimental chamber while performing sedentary tasks and active tasks.”

“The mean per cent penetration for each mask material ranged from 0.26% to 29%, depending on the flow rate and mask material. In the volunteer tests, the average total inward leakage (TIL) of BC ranged from 3% to 68% in the sedentary tests and from 7% to 66% in the active tests. Only one mask type tested showed an average TIL of less than 10%, under both test conditions.

Conclusions:  Many commercially available face masks may not provide adequate protection, primarily due to poor facial fit. Our results indicate that further attention should be given to mask design and providing evidence based guidance to consumers.”

In other words, the leakage rates can easily go as high as 50%...

The bottom-line is that it may be better to use nasal filters [3,4] based on nanofibre technology by IIT-D, but the ones recently developed also have different sizes, and are stated to be equivalent to N95 masks. Since they have to be sized relative to the size of your nostrils, the same caveats may apply…



References:

1. A.C.K.Lai et al J. Roy. Soc. Interface 9 (2012) 938–948
2. J.W.Cherrie…M.Loh Occup Environ Med 75 (2018) 446–452. doi:10.1136/oemed-2017-104765

Friday, October 19, 2018

Anti-tourism manifesto


An anti-tourism manifesto

Not exactly and completely anti-tourism, but close enough:

I do not endorse long-distance air travel because of its very high greenhouse gas footprint. Long distance travel by road, train or ship consume way too much time. Air travel within India is acceptable – just so long as it is not too frequent.

Also I am lazy and stingy so international travel is a problem. Visa rules are getting to be much more stringent (British rules are exemplary!), and the natives of many countries are becoming increasingly unfriendly. Better to get murdered in your own country (also becoming more and more likely)!

There is now no terra incognita, no unmapped legendary Shangri La for an adventurous Marco Polo to seek out. 

We can talk about re-enactment tourism like visiting NZ to see the locales where LOTR was shot, or Abbey Road where the Beatles stood, or any other memory that strikes you at a given time. But as Dubrovnik in Croatia will attest, over-tourism is a fact of life; better just watch GoT on HD-TV!

Pilgrimages, like the Amarnath or Kailash Manasrover Yatras, have to be actually undergone on foot for it to ‘count’, but for the rest, VR will do just fine, thank you!

Instead of actually going anywhere I would advocate armchair tourism. I just finished visiting the Tatra mountains of Poland courtesy of my laptop. I can go check out the Torres del Paine in Patagonia next… One may even go so far as to contemplate VR tourism. For example, one can visit the Louvre online. OK, it requires a good broadband connection.

Admittedly you cannot get to smell the air or touch the soil, but with rapidly-developing haptic sensors the latter should be possible soon at a commercial level for a paying customer. Smells? Well, some of them are doable… the others, they are still working on.

Anyway, with VR you can tour worlds that do not even exist…or you could just read Pico Iyer.

Let us face it: you get less than 100 bits per sec through your senses. 


"The unconscious processing abilities of the human brain are estimated at roughly 11 million bits per second. Compare that to the estimate for conscious processing: about 40 bits per second."



"The maximum information rate at which we humans can learn is only a few tens of bits per second. Our eyes and ears do not impose this is low information rate. It is limited by the need for our brain to integrate what we sense into our internal mental model of the world."


VR, at present, is still a bit clunky. I have experienced VR just once, at the Kiran Nadar Museum: "Kalimpong (2016)" by Shezad Dawood. There was no sound (as there is elsewhere) and I was lucky I did not trip on the wires attached to the headset, but having said that, the 3D was pretty good and Dawood has done a really good job of visualizing the town of Kalimpong with the surrounding mountains and the obligatory Yeti.  Certainly the resolution could be better, but you can indeed pick up a book in the library. 

By comparison, I saw a couple of short treks of the Werribee Gorge hikes in Australia in 4K and it's close to being there:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ht04Sn04FXU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGzGmnyIghY

But you did not get all the aches and pains (that could be a plus or a minus)!

And there are now drone's-eye views of practically anything, available on the internet. The stuff is being uploaded at unbelievable rates onto the internet. 

For couch potatos: ....the future belongs to you! Others may huff and puff all the way up Everest, but they will upload breathtaking 360 degree views...just to prove they dunnit...and the couch potato may subscribe to their channels...or not.

It does not matter where you are: you could be travelling in Greece or you could be watching a video or a movie in a theatre. Your brain, with its limited processing capacity, will (soon) be unable to tell the difference.


Want to meet people? Just Skype!

They always urged you to travel to broaden your mind. Now we have the Internet, you do not need to travel any more.

Travel is passe.

Travel is for the birds. Migratory birds, not the sensible ones.



Sunday, July 1, 2018

Nesbit's rule and 'chameleon technologies'


Nesbit’s rule and ‘chameleon’ technologies

“And there’s a dreadful law here … that if any one asks for machinery they have to have it and keep on using it.” – Edith Nesbit (1910) in  “The Magic City”.

 The physicist Freeman Dyson quotes Edith Nesbit in his 1979 book “Disturbing the Universe” and adds that he realized that Nesbit’s “Magic City”  is, in fact, our own world. He applies Nesbit’s rule to cars, nylons and nuclear weapons. Dyson also points out that the scientific endeavor is, in principle, unpredictable. We do not get to pick whether the toys we asked for are good or bad. (The problem is even more acute, with toys that are both good and bad.) And some inventions (Dyson notes) – again unpredictably – proliferate madly, while the large majority fall by the wayside.
It may takes decades before the scientific community realizes that an apparently innocuous, beneficial technology has global negative effects. Since these technologies were so obviously innocuous and beneficial, they were widely accepted and spread rapidly (so-called ‘technology diffusion’). In fact, it is a no-brainer that such a beneficial technology will have global outreach.

Such obviously dangerous technologies like nuclear reactors and nuclear weapons are not discussed here. Although one might mention that nuclear meltdowns may be the least of our problems, since nuclear winter is likely to have even more far-reaching and long-lasting consequences.

Four examples of such technologies are obvious (although there are bound to be others that I have overlooked e.g. asbestos and genetically modified organisms, GMOs):

a)      DDT and other similar pesticides: Rachel Carson gave a wake-up call with her book ‘Silent Spring’ in 1962. (DDT was invented in 1939 and used in World War Two to control malaria).

b)       CFCs were first used for refrigeration in 1928 (that preserved foods and medicines for long time periods) started causing ozone depletion (banned in 1996) and hence skin cancer.

c)       Plastics, invented much earlier but widely introduced by the 1960’s, have been found floating in the Pacific Ocean in at least 80,000 tons, in the last 5 years [1]. Are plastics safe for human consumption? Maybe, maybe not. But microbeads are unlikely to be safe.

d)      The internal combustion engine combined with fossil fuels has contributed significantly to human progress (the model T was rolled out by Ford in 1908) – and to pollution and, more importantly, global warming. At this point, the possibility of a runaway greenhouse effect – which would turn Earth into Venus – cannot be ruled out, although it would be described as being unduly alarmist, Cassandra-like.

DDT was outed within two decades… but the global warming story is at the other end of the spectrum. The Swedish physicist Svante Arrhenius proposed in 1896 that fossil fuel burning will increase the average temperature of the atmosphere, and various scientists persevered with the basic idea, but it was not till 1988 that most experts were agreed that doubling CO2 in the atmosphere would raise average temperature by 1 °C [2], and in 2001 that the Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) issued a formal statement agreed by consensus… and even today many governments are not in agreement. That is closer to 120 years…

It is ironic that the fact that plastics remain stable for thousands of years, and their being virtually indestructible  - a highly desirable trait -  should come back to bite us. These plastics reach the oceans via streams, rivers and beaches and now slosh around over thousands of square kilometers in the oceans… So now we are trying to ban plastic straws, but still cling on to cling wrap to keep food fresh and hygienic.

It is obvious to anyone that each of the above inventions seemed to be ‘safe’ and came with enormous benefits. Also, none of these technologies is dangerous - unless they are widely used by a large human population, which is large and still increasing… These technologies have morphed into dangerous forms, so they may be referred to as ‘chameleon’ technologies.

With hindsight, today we can claim that we know better - but it is unclear if we will be able to identify future ‘chameleon’ technologies (for the same reason that Dyson gave). The problems that we have with statistics are significant: it took a long time even to rigorously prove that nuclear radiation is bad for people in a statistically significant way. We have supercomputers and neural networks and are on our way to creating multi-purpose artificial intelligence, but we are not able to foresee the consequences of all our actions. It may be, in principle, impossible.

The precautionary principle, propounded by environmentalists, suggests that we should avoid any actions that may cause harm – but will we give up our cellphones? Or just keep them away from the heads of young children? Critics would argue that the precautionary principle, strictly applied, would lead to paralysis. It would be foolish to give up on development when we have the power (we think) to eradicate poverty? The train is moving too fast for us to stop it (even if we wanted to); it’s more akin to a juggernaut. Indeed we share a quasi-religious faith in progress, driven by S & T.

Environmentalists have been giving significant negative feedback on the fallout from S & T. Perhaps one of the most significant was the Limits to Growth report of the Club of Rome in 1972 [3]. It was widely criticized because its predictions were doom-and-gloom. Contrary to their predictions, no mass famines occurred in Asia and Africa, for example. Nevertheless, their basic idea – that the Earth has a finite ‘carrying capacity’ – has been accepted. So the concept of the ecological footprint of each person has become commonplace, and sustainability is the buzzword. We ask how many Earths do we need to meet the lifestyle aspirations of every human being?

However, though the human condition has improved – as can be seen from life expectancy figures almost all over the world - the same cannot be said for species other than humans (and their client species). They are dying out in huge numbers, an extinction event that is unparalleled in history. There is no evidence that the rate of extinction of species is slowing down. A 2014 study by Pimm et al [4] stated that the rate of extinction is a thousand times higher today than in the absence of humans (the ‘background’ extinction rate). For example, Lovejoy’s research (quoted in Elizabeth Kolbert’s book [5]) has shown that the fragmentation of forest habitats (by human activity) drastically reduces species diversity. And if we add the multiplier effect of anthropogenic global warming, even fewer species will be able to adapt.

So what is meant by ‘sustainable growth’? Can we ‘sustain’ the Sixth Extinction [5]?

Many scientists and technologists are inherently optimistic (which is why the Limits to Growth report was unpopular). They believe that any problem created by technology can be solved by more technology (‘techno-fix’). CFCs can be replaced by some other refrigerant that will not destroy ozone. Pollution emitted by cars can be handled by catalytic converters, low sulphur fuels etc – and, if all else fails, just wear a mask! An inexpensive solution can be found to bury all the carbon dioxide that humans emit (in the ocean, in limestone, etc.).

However, it is far from obvious that this optimism is justified. S & T have amplified our powers to the extent that all our actions have global consequences, while the rest of the world would like to catch up with unsustainable Western lifestyles (how many Earths?).

At one level, there is no need to worry: in the worst case, we may manage to wipe out all forms of life other than cockroaches, tardigrades and bacteria (including us, of course). So what? The system will reboot, as it has done in the past. It’s just that we won’t be there to see it.

As of now, there is no Plan(et) B, although there are plans by Elon Musk to set up a base on Mars [6], and by Lockheed Martin [7]…

One problem with S & T is that it accelerates. Heidi and Alvin Toffler pointed out in their 1970 book ‘Future shock’ that many people would be left behind by all these exponential changes. However, if it takes us decades to figure out which apparently excellent ‘chameleon’ ideas are best avoided, while the train is going faster and faster all the time, even AI may not save us!

In fact, AI itself may be a chameleon technology, if we believe warnings by Stephen Hawking [8] and Elon Musk [9]…

References:
1    1)   a) A.Cozar et al PNAS2014 and b)  https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/great-pacific-garbage-patch-plastic-pollution-oceans-environment-fish-a8269951.html

3    3) “The Limits to Growth” D.H.Meadows et al (A Potomac Associates book, 1972)
4    4)  S.Pimm et al Science 344 (2014) 987 “The biodiversity of species and their rates of extinction, distribution, and protection”
5    5)      “The Sixth Extinction: an unnatural history”, Elizabeth Kolbert

7) https://www.popsci.com/lockheed-martins-plan-to-set-up-mars-base-camp


Saturday, December 30, 2017

My experience with air purifiers in polluted Delhi

My experience with air purifiers in polluted Delhi

Since the year ends today, I would like to share my experience and simple analysis of two air purifiers that I own, in Delhi: one from Philips and the other from Smart Air.

Background & CADR:


As pointed out in the above website, air purifiers come in two styles: tower-type (the Philips) and box-type (Smart Air):

“Tower Air Purifier - the tower design, as the name suggests is shaped like a tower. These tend to be taller with a smaller footprint, so they take up less floor space. Given the design, the filters are smaller and often have lower air flows.

Box Style - the box shaped air purifier has more of a square shape. The advantage of the box style is the larger surface area of the filter. This allows it to more easily move more air with a lower pressure drop. As a result, the box style can clean larger room sizes and provide cleaner air.”

My experience is similar, but I should add that the higher the speed setting, the more efficient is the air purifier. And you should opt for an air purifier with the highest CADR (see below). Unfortunately, the higher the speed, the noisier the purifier – which is a problem if you want to sleep and are sensitive to even white noise.
The main issue for me is: how effective is the air purifier? To answer this question, I took readings of PM2.5 and PM10 with my AirVeda particle monitor (in mg/m3), and tried to compare them with reported values. Unfortunately, the air purifiers are not as effective as claimed/reported.


For example, Smart Air reports in Beijing, that their air purifier reduced the particle concentration from 1,000 mg/m3 to 100 mg/m3 in 20 mins with all doors and windows closed, but by only 60% (to 400 mg/m3) if one window was left open. My experience in Delhi is that on Diwali day, you cannot get the particle concentration below 300 mg/m3 no matter how long you wait. A caveat, however: I used a Philips air purifier and I did not use the highest speed setting. Next time I won’t make the same mistake. I am left with a doubt: is it that rooms in Beijing are more airtight than those in Delhi, since it is a lot colder in Beijing? Is that what makes the difference?


I should note that there is a difference between the cfm (cubic feet per minute) of the air purifier and its CADR (clean air delivery rate):
CADR = (filter efficiency) X (cfm)
For a HEPA (high efficiency particulate air) filter with 99.7% efficiency, they are almost the same, but for a 40% efficiency filter, the CADR is that much smaller (by 2.5X). Both the air purifiers that I have use HEPA filters.


"The CADR shows you how much air is coming out of the purifier," says Bapat, "and it should change the air in the room at least five times per hour. Otherwise, you're not going to be breathing clean air." (Girish Bapat, Director, West and South Asia for the Swedish company Blueair).


“The CADR is a measure of a portable air cleaner’s delivery of contaminant-free air, expressed in cubic feet per minute. For example, an air cleaner that has a CADR of 250 for dust particles can reduce dust particle levels to the same concentration as would be achieved by adding 250 cfm of clean air. The portable air cleaner’s removal rate competes with other removal processes occurring in the space, including deposition of particles on surfaces, sorption of gases, indoor air chemical reactions, and outdoor air exchange. While a portable air cleaner may not achieve its rated CADR under all circumstances, the CADR value does allow comparisons among portable air cleaners.”

Simple model:

My experience with plotting the PM10 & PM2.5 concentrations with respect to time is that they decrease exponentially. So I am following a simple model, as below:
Let r be the PM concentration in mg/m3 in a closed room, and rout be the PM outside.
The rate of change of PM is:

                                dr/dt = b - ar

Where b is the in-leak rate into the room (sealing is imperfect), in units of mg/m3/min.
The solution is:

                                r = (b/a) – (b/a - r0) exp(-at) = bt - (bt - r0) exp( - t/t)

Where r0 is the initial PM value. The parameter a = 1/t, in the fits to experimental data.
The parameter b is given by:
                                 b = rout (1/V)(dV/dt)

Where dV/dt is the volume in-leak rate and V is the volume of the room.
The parameter t is given by:

                                t = khV/Vap

Where Vap is the volume rate at which the air purifier fan pushes air through it, h is the filter efficiency of the air purifier (close to unity) and k is a constant of proportionality that accounts for the fact that t is much larger than V/Vap.
Note: I have not specifically considered particle generation within the room, nor have I taken into account the settling of particles, mainly because the settling time is inversely proportional to the square of the particle radius. For PM2.5 particles this goes into hours.

Calculations & readings:


Room Volume = (169)(9) = 1521 ft3 = 43.1 m3. The Philips air purifier has Vap = 279 m3/hr = 4.65 m3/min. So V/Vap = 43.1/4.65 = 9.3 mins. However, experimentally t is greater than this value (up to 3X).






Note: a) The AirVeda particle monitor reading for PM10 is only for particles in the size range 2.5 -10 microns and does not include those that are less than 2.5 microns 
b) the readings are stable values, but ideally one should take a large number of readings and then smooth the curve. I have not done this.

The PM2.5 on 5Nov.17 is fitted to:  13.63 + 147.8 exp(-t/27.83)
And the PM10 to: 23.09 + 220.7 exp(-t/30.61)

Unfortunately the concentrations outside changed during the afternoon:

t
PM2.5
PM10
13:45
153
239
14:40
132
202
16:00
115
175

The limiting value should be determined by the last set of PM values.
For PM2.5, the intercept is 13.63 = b (27.83), so b = 0.49 mg/m3/min.
Similarly, for PM10,  b = 23.09/30.61 = 0.75.
Using the equation for b, for PM2.5, dV/dt = (43.1)(0.49)/115 = 0.18  m3/min.
For PM10, dV/dt = (43.1)(0.75)/175 = 0.18 m3/min.
The fact that we get the same estimated dV/dt for both particle sizes is nice.
This number 0.18 m3/min equates to 10.8 m3/hr, while the room volume is 43 m3. That is, an air change of the whole room due to the in-leak would need about 4 hrs. The AHAM (Association of Home Appliances Manufacturers) criterion is that the in-leak should not be more than 1 air change per hour (1 ACH), used to calculate the maximum room size for which an air purifier is rated.
I won’t go into detail, but I will just tabulate the time constants for PM2.5 and PM10 for several days, as well as the other coefficients y0 (bt) and A0 (r0 - bt). There is day-to-day variation, and that is even disregarding the fact that I changed the speed setting (to the highest setting, speed 3) or used a different room or used two air purifiers at once (on 8th Nov, which almost doubled the speed):

Date
Conditions
PM2.5 (mins)
PM10 (mins)
b2.5, b10 (mg/m3/min.)
31st Oct17
Philips
27 + 117 exp(-t/27.6)
48 + 177 exp(-t/29.3)
0.98; 1.64
3rd Nov17
Philips
24 + 111 exp(-t/23.7)
40 + 179 exp(-t/24.0)
1.01 ; 0.99
5th Nov17
Smart Air
14 + 148 exp(-t/27.8)
23 +221 exp(-t/30.6)
1.01; 0.75
8th Nov17
Smart Air & Philips
15+ 96 exp(-t/14.5)
33+200 exp(-t/17.0)
1.03; 1.94
9th Nov17
Smart Air (living room)
36 + 268 exp(-t/36.5)
77 + 424 exp(-t/36.8)
0.99; 2.09
21st Nov17
Philips
31 + 81 exp(-t/26.3)
57 + 176 exp(-t/30.7)
1.18; 1.86
29th Nov17
Philips speed 3
15 + 136 exp(-t/14.8)
38 + 226 exp(-t/14.2)
1.01; 2.67
30th Nov17
Philips speed 3
22 + 139 exp(-t/12.6)
37 + 233 exp(-t/12.6)
1.74; 2.93
21st Dec17
Philips speed 3
56 + 263 exp(-t/20.7)
104 + 354 exp(-t/21.7)
2.70; 4.79

The living room volume (9th Nov) is almost the same as the bedroom, but it has a sliding door. Clearly there is significant variation in the parameter b (which is the product of the in-leak rate dV/dt and the outside concentration rout, divided by the room volume V) as can be seen from the last column values for PM2.5 and PM10 (b2.5, b10). That is, you may get high ingress of pollutant particles if either the outside air has a high concentration of PM or if the in-leak rate into your room is high. Like if you leave a window or door open. But even if doors and windows are closed, there is space under the door or between windows and window-frames for air to get in. All the readings above are with all doors and windows closed – and with a filler shoved under the doors to my bedroom.
Which is why I am skeptical of the claim of reducing particle concentration from 1,000 mg/m3 to 100 mg/m3 in 20 mins, and even lower with greater time. For example, today’s readings: outside PM2.5 is 447 mg/m3 and PM10 is 677 mg/m3 which is high even for Delhi, but lower than Diwali levels. At the highest speed setting, all doors and windows closed, under-door filler in place, inside my bedroom the stabilized value of PM2.5 is 65 and PM10 is 107. This is just barely acceptable – even by lax Indian standards for PM2.5 (60 mg/m3). WHO recommends 20 mg/m3.  And some recent studies suggest even lower values. So don’t even ask what will happen on Diwali… I will probably need two air purifiers running full blast – and then to wear a N99 mask! Or, I should get hold of room-sealing experts...

Factors influencing In-leak rate:

There are three driving factors that influence in-leak (apart from geometry), in descending order of strength:
a a)      Temperature
b b)    Pressure
c c)    Wind speed

Considering that 300 K corresponds to 1013 mb, 1K (or 1 °C) corresponds to 3.38 mb.
And a wind speed of 10 m/s (36 km/hr) corresponds to (1.2)(100)/2 = 60 Pa or 0.6 mb.
In Delhi, wind speed mostly is around, or below, 10 m/s.
On a typical day, atmospheric pressure may move up or down by about ±5 mb in Delhi.
(i)                   In the course of the day, if the pressure is falling, the inside pressure will always lag behind the outside pressure, so air will flow outwards. Similarly, if the outside pressure increases over a period of time, air will flow into a building. How much flow happens will depend upon the size of openings (doors, windows, cracks, etc).
(ii)                The temperature of rooms inside lags the outside temperature by a few hours. Starting in the morning, as outside temperature increases, air will flow into the building. After sunset, similarly, outside temperature will drop and air will flow outwards.
(iii)               But what happens if both outside temperature and pressure are varying? There are four possibilities:

Outside temperature
Outside pressure
Flow
Increasing
Increasing
Inwards
Increasing
Decreasing
Depends on relative changes
Decreasing
Increasing
Depends on relative changes
Decreasing
Decreasing
Outwards

Estimating the time constant:

I am trying to estimate the time required to purify the room air, so here goes with a fairly crude argument:

Assume V = 43 m3 and air purifier (AP) flow-rate of 4.3 m3/min. That means 10 volumes or ‘packets’ of air.
Suppose we start when the air purifier is switched on: all 10 packets of air are ‘dirty’, so the time required for one 4.3 m3 packet to reach the air purifier and cross it is 1 min. At the other end, suppose all packets have been cleaned up except one. Then the time required for it to reach the air purifier varies between 1 and 10 mins, with an average of about 5.5 mins – but the maximum time is 10 mins. If there were 2 dirty packets of air, the time required would vary between 1 & 5 mins with an average of 3 mins, and max of 5 mins.

Extending the same logic, the maximum time for cleaning all packets = [(10/1) + (10/2) + (10/3) + … + (10/10)] @ 10 [0.5772 + ln(10)] = 10 [ 0.5772 + 2.301] = 28.78 mins, where 0.5772 is Euler’s constant, using the approximation for the harmonic series. Without the approximation it is: 29.24 mins (by just adding up the numbers).
The average time would be: [5.5 + 3 + 2.1 + 1.7 + 1.5 + 1.3 + 1.2 + 1.1 + 1.05 +1] = 19.5 mins.
But 10 mins is what it would take with perfect efficiency, 19.5 mins on an average. The best time constant I got is 12.6 mins on 30th Nov17. But that is just the 1/e time constant (63% clean-up), whereas the above argument refers to a 100% clean-up… that should be roughly 3 time constants…but it does not take into account the in-leak so the comparison is iffy…
Also the air, after being purified, is expelled from the air purifier with some speed. If that speed is high, the air packet may not come back to the air purifier quickly, reducing the random factor and the probability of double- or triple-purification…So the airflow is neither perfectly 1-D  nor perfectly random.
This argument assumes randomness – but the air flow is probably chaotic, not random, so the time may work out to be between 10 and 19.5 mins (‘chaos’ means that there are some elements of order in the air flows). However, looking at chaos is above my pay grade! Maybe somebody can enlighten me…
The analysis of the in-leak rate is, as indicated above, dependent on data of wind-speed, temperature (inside and outside) and atmospheric pressure (inside and outside). I tried assuming that, after the air purifier is switched off, to fit the increase in particle concentration to a simple exponential:
 Y = y0 + A0 ( 1 – exp(-t/t))
But it did not work. The situation with variable v, Tin and Tout, pin and pout, is more complicated. I have to look for a better model.